Classic YA fiction by Elizabeth George Speare

I was watching the grandkids play and perusing a shelf of older books. A title, Calico Captive by Elizabeth George Speare, caught my eye. Before long, I was reading and glancing over at the kids from time to time. When I taught middle grades (long, long ago) I used Speare’s The Witch of Blackbird Pond as one of my class novels. I’m not sure that all of the students liked it, but I did. Calico Captive, like “Witch” is an historical novel, with a young adult protagonist.

Nowadays, many novelists write for younger audiences, and the readership is quite broad for such novels. Everything from Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone to The Hunger Games (Book 1) to The Princess Diaries  are squarely aimed at YA, but caught on with adults and movie audiences, too. Speare’s novels are very well written and could have a varied audience of entertained readers. Instead of re-cycling old television shows, maybe some film makers will decide to put Elizabeth George Speare’s tales into production. This novel would make a great movie!

Calico Captive tells the story of a young woman, Miriam Willard, living on the frontier in the 1700s; first captured by Indians, then held more or less as a prisoner of war by the French, during what historians now call the French-Indian War. According to my research, this is Speare’s debut novel, and it is based on a real life story. Miriam and her fellow captives are portrayed in a manner that held my interest. Okay, it is not quite a page turner, as it strives for some historical accuracy meaning that this all takes a while to resolve, but this story also helped me learn about a period of history that I don’t know well at all.

Readers who love history and are looking for a well written novel with adventure and a hint of romance will really enjoy this story. Speare’s later, better known works, are good reads also, but I have genuinely enjoyed this window into another time.

Netflix? Hulu? Amazon? Come on, let’s get these stories into production!

Best Short Stories

Not too long ago, I heard a real life tale of woe which reminded me of “The Necklace” by Guy de Maupassant. For anyone who didn’t read it during school, this little gem has a memorable main character, a setting in old Paris, both internal and external conflict, and a plot which can be either satisfying or disturbing. Oh, and its strong point is its cautionary theme. I’ve read any number of novels which did not have as many literary elements as “The Necklace.” Is it the best short story ever? I don’t know, but I’d put it in the running.

So, what’s the competition for best short story? There are many, but some my favorites include Frank Stockton’s “The Lady or the Tiger?” which is long on plot, but it also has a nifty historical setting and enough characterization to keep readers interested. Others which have great plots include “The Most Dangerous Game” by Richard Connell, a marvelous adventure story which has often been the springboard for a number of movies. Any time the plot of a movie or television show includes a human being hunted by another, I always think of Connell’s version. Another story which has a dramatic plot is Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery.” A longer, plot driven short story, but one with far more character development, as well as a beautifully rendered setting is “The Birds” by Daphne du Maurier. Most people who hear the title, The Birds, think of the Alfred Hitchcock movie, which is very loosely based on the short story, but I like du Maurier’s version better.

The stories I’ve mentioned thus far are frequently anthologized, so I posted links to them. But, before I leave the topic of best short stories, I must include some science fiction, which is a favorite genre, but one which doesn’t usually make it into anthologies. My favorite sci fi short stories include the thematically strong “There will Come Soft Rains” by Ray Bradbury and “Feeding Time” by James E. Gunn. I love ironic plot twists, and the Gunn story has a perfect ending.

By and large, I prefer to read novel length fiction, but the short story has its place. Many writers have been masters of the short story, such as Poe and O’Henry. Like poetry, the short story is a more compressed format, so the writer has to do more with less, and that can be difficult. There are any number of ho-hum short stories, but when the author gets it right, the result is a masterpiece.